IMPACT WASHING AND GREEN WASHING

Accelerate your business with these expert tips on Impact Washing and green washing.

Analyse and discover this TIP!

"Impact Washing

The term "Impact Washing refers to the practice of some companies that claim to have a positive social or environmental impact without backing it up with tangible or significant actions. Essentially, these companies use the social impact or sustainability language as a marketing toolwithout actually living up to those ideals.

Signs to identify "Impact Washing

• Lack of Measurement and Evidence: The company does not provide metrics or evidence to support its claims of positive impact.
• Inconsistencies in the Report: Annual and sustainability reports show inconsistencies or lack clarity and transparency.
• Discrepancy between Advertising and Practice: Big marketing campaigns that talk about social impact, but few tangible actions to prove it.
• Absence of Third Party Certifications: They do not have certifications such as B Corp, Fair Trade, etc., to back up their claims.
• Lack of long-term commitment: Impact projects are short-term or one-off, rather than an integral part of the business strategy.
  Benefit and Common Interest Companies

In order to avoid "Impact Washing" and to ensure transparency and legal certainty in the new model of social enterprises, such as Benefit and Common Interest Companies, it is important:

• Legal Structure: Ensure that the company has a legal structure that obliges it to consider social and environmental impact in addition to economic benefit.
• Certifications: Obtain third-party certifications (such as B Corp) that audit and verify the company's social and environmental impact.
• Transparency: Publish annual reports showing both financial metrics and third-party audited social and environmental impact metrics.
• Inclusion of Stakeholders: Include in decision-making not only shareholders, but also stakeholders affected by the company's activities.
• Legislation and Regulation: Support and adhere to legislation that promotes transparency and accountability in terms of social and environmental impact.

By adhering to these principles, companies can offer greater transparency and legal certaintyand thus avoid falling into "Impact Washing" practices.

Impact Washing" is a sensitive issue and it is important to bear in mind that the accusations in this regard may have serious implications for the legal and reputational implications for the companies involved. That said, here are a few general forms in which companies could become involved in Impact Washing practices.

Practical examples:

• Fake Organic Products: A company could launch a "green" line of products and make a strong marketing campaign around their supposedly positive environmental impact. However, if the manufacture of these products is still harmful to the environment, this could be considered "Impact Washing".
• Donation Pledges: A company might promise that a certain amount from each sale goes to a charitable cause, but in reality, that donation may be minimal or non-existent.
• Diversity Initiatives: Another way might be to promote diversity and inclusion policies in the workplace, but not to make substantive changes in hiring, promotion or corporate culture that support these claims.
• False or Irrelevant Certificates: Use seals and certificates on packaging that appear important but do not have significant authority or verification.
• Name Change or Rebranding: Some companies may attempt to change their image by simply changing their name or logo to include words such as "green", "ethical" or "sustainable" without making operational changes to back up these claims.
• Disinformation on Social Networks: Posting photos, videos or stories on social media that show social or environmental impact actions that are staged or exaggerated.

These are only general examples and are not intended to single out any particular company. The key to identifying "Impact Washing". is always to look beyond marketing statements and examine the actual actions of the company and their verifiable impact.

"greenwashing

The term "greenwashing refers to the practice of making misleading or exaggerated claims about environmental sustainability of a product, service, technology or company. The objective is to create a perception of environmental responsibility for attracting eco-conscious consumersalthough the statements are not completely true or are misleading.

For examplea company can labelling a product as "environmentally friendly" or "sustainable". even if it has only carried out minimal changes that do not have a significant impact on the sustainability of the product. It may also be that the "green" aspects of the product is exaggerated promotionwhile the ignored or downplayed other negative environmental aspects related to their production, distribution or disposal.

Greenwashing tactics may include:

• Misleading Advertising: Using images or language that suggest an environmental approach that is not supported by business practices.
• False or Meaningless Environmental Labels: Use of labels such as "natural", "green" or "eco-friendly" without a clear standard or independent verification.
• Ambiguity: Use of vague or unclear terms that can make a product appear more sustainable than it really is.
• Concealment of information: Not disclosing the full environmental impact of a product or focusing only on a positive aspect while ignoring the negative ones.

It is important to be critical and do proper research before accepting the sustainability claims of a company. There is trusted organisations and certifications that can help identify truly sustainable products and services.

Differences between impact washing y greenwhasing

Both "greenwashing" and "impact washing" are forms of deceptive marketing, but they differ in the scope in which they operate and in what they attempt to project:

Greenwashing

• Scope: Mainly focused on environmental issues.
• Objective: To convince the public that an organisation is more environmentally friendly than it really is.
• Tactics: It uses language, images and labels that evoke environmental sustainability.
• Common Industries: Most prevalent in sectors such as energy, consumer products, fashion and technology.
• Examples: Labelling a product as "biodegradable" when it is not fully biodegradable, or advertising a small green initiative while continuing unsustainable practices on a large scale.

Impact Washing

• Scope: It goes beyond the environment to include social, economic and governance (ESG) impacts.
• Objective: Give the impression that an organisation has a positive social or ESG impact beyond its pursuit of profit, when this is not the case.
• Tactics: It uses impact metrics, reports and certifications to appear high on accountability without real or meaningful change in the company's operations.
• Common Industries: It is often found in the financial sector, but can also occur in any industry that talks about social impact or ESG.
• Examples: Investment funds that claim to be "impact" but invest in companies with questionable labour or environmental practices; companies that highlight small donations or corporate social responsibility initiatives while engaging in unethical practices in other areas.

Similarities between impact washing y greenwhasing

• Deception: Both are forms of marketing that can mislead the consumer.
• Image Manipulation: Both greenwashing and impact washing aim to improve the public image of a company or product.
• Lack of Verification: In both cases, claims often lack independent verification or certification.
• Risk to the Brand: Both practices put the company's reputation at risk if the deception is discovered.

In short, while the greenwashing focuses on the environmentthe impact washing has a broader scope which also includes aspects of social and governance. Both are problematic because misinform the consumer and can divert attention and the resources for more effective and genuine solutions

How can an entrepreneur avoid the temptation of creating a impact washing?

For avoiding temptation of "Impact Washing", an entrepreneur can continue to several steps that help to ensure that your company is genuinely committed to social or environmental impact that promises. Here are some recommendations:

1. Authenticity and Clarity of Mission
   Establish from the outset a clear and authentic mission that focuses on a specific social or environmental impact. The mission should be embedded in the business strategy and not just a marketing slogan.
2. Transparency
   Be fully transparent about the company's operations, impact and goals. Publish annual reports and regular updates on progress towards impact targets.
3. Measuring Impact
   Use verifiable tools and metrics to measure the social and/or environmental impact of the company. Tools such as the B Impact Assessment or specific Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) can be useful.
4. External Verification
   Seek third-party certification, such as B Corp or ISO certification, which assesses and confirms the company's ethical and sustainable practices.
5. Stakeholder Engagement
   Involve employees, customers, suppliers and communities in the decision-making process, especially when those decisions affect social or environmental impact.
6. Honesty in Marketing
   Avoid making exaggerated or false claims in marketing and advertising campaigns. Instead, focus on communicating real efforts and achievements, backed by data.
7. Revision and Constant Adjustments
   Conduct regular internal and external audits to ensure that the company is on track to achieve its desired impact and make adjustments as necessary.
8. Education and Training
   Educate all staff on the importance of the impact mission and how each role within the company contributes to that mission.
9. Accepting and Learning from Mistakes
   If you identify areas where the company falls short in its impact, be open about these challenges and take concrete steps to improve.
10. Creating a Culture of Impact
    Finally, but perhaps most importantly, is to create a business culture that values social and environmental impact as much as financial performance.

By following these guidelinesan entrepreneur can working to ensure that your company is effectively committed to a genuine social or environmental impact.

Artificial intelligence can be a useful tool to avoid "Impact Washing" in a number of ways:

1. Formulation of the Mission and Objectives
   Artificial intelligence can help articulate and review your company's mission and objectives, ensuring that they are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-based (SMART). A well-defined mission that is integrated into all areas of the business is a first step to avoid "Impact Washing".
2. Developing Impact Strategies
   You can solicit ideas or strategies that align with your mission and objectives. Artificial intelligence can provide examples and best practices in your industry to ensure your impact strategy is effective and authentic.
3. Drafting of Impact Reports
   Artificial intelligence can help write impact reports that are clear, transparent and backed by data. These reports can be shared with stakeholders to show real progress towards impact objectives.
4. Education and Awareness Raising
   It can use artificial intelligence to create educational materials for employees, partners and customers, fostering a culture of genuine impact across the company.
5. Preparation for Audits and Certifications
   Artificial intelligence can help prepare documentation and answers to common questions that may arise during the third-party certification process, such as B Corp certification.
6. Research and Development
   If you are looking for new ways to expand your impact, artificial intelligence can help with initial research, providing information on industry trends, case studies and emerging technologies that might align with your objectives.
7. Marketing and Communication Validation
   Before launching marketing campaigns that make claims about their impact, you can use artificial intelligence to review messages to ensure they are accurate and not misleading.
8. Feedback Analysis
   If you collect feedback from stakeholders on your performance in terms of impact, you can use artificial intelligence to analyse this information and develop action plans based on the feedback.
9. Questions and Answers in Real Time
   If you have specific questions or need clarification on how to avoid "Impact Washing", you can ask questions in real time and get immediate answers.
10. Continuous Monitoring
    Finally, you can use artificial intelligence for regular reminders to review and update your impact strategies, ensuring they remain current and authentic.

By using artificial intelligence in these various capacities, you can increase the likelihood that your company will maintain a genuine focus on creating social or environmental impact.